sabato 27 settembre 2014

Court of Appeal reverses Grosseto ruling

Court of Appeal of Florence 
On September 23 the Court of Appeal of Florence reversed the April Grosseto ruling which ordered the recognition of the first same-sex marriage in Italy. 










The Court of Appeal reversed the lower decision of judge Paolo Cesare Otatti due to a problem of "standings". According to the Court, the couple - Giuseppe and Stefano - would have appointed the Mayor as the defendant and not the Comune (County) and this mistake could have been solved if the Mayor of Grosseto, Emilio Bonifazi (Democratic Party), had appeared before the Court. Now the case is remanded to the District Court of Grosseto.

Giuseppe and Stefano married in New York in 2012 and then sued the Comune of Grosseto in March 2014, judge Paolo Ottati decided the only a month later.

domenica 13 luglio 2014

Ritorno al futuro: lo stato dello Utah porterà il caso Kitchen dinanzi alla Corte Suprema


Il 25 giugno scorso, la Corte d'Appello di Denver del 10° Circuito degli Appelli (d'ora in poi solo 10° Circuito) aveva deciso in favore di quelle coppie gay e lesbiche che l'anno scorso avevano iniziato un'azione legale contro il divieto al diritto al matrimonio nello stato dell'Utah. Se vi ricordate, il 20 dicembre 2013 il giuidice federale Shelby aveva accolto la richiesta delle coppie (qui la decisione), ed ora il 10° Circuito ha confermato la sentenza del giudice Shelby (qui la sentenza d'appello); quello che manca è un'ulteriore appello alla Corte Suprema.

Fino a qualche giorno fa - per la precisione il 9 luglio - lo stato dello Utah aveva avuto la possibilità di appellarsi nuovamente al 10° Circuito e, questa volta, tutti i giudici di questo Circuito avrebbero potuto prendere parte al caso Kitchen (questo tipo di giudizio prende il nome di en banc review). Così non è stato. Il 9 luglio lo stato dello Utah ha detto che avrebbe preferito chiedere alla Corte Suprema di rivedere il caso. E così sarà.

Ma da ieri, i tempi per appellarsi si sono accorciati. Gli stessi giudici che avevano presediuto al caso Kitchen - Kelly, Lucero e Holmes - hanno ordinato allo Utah di riconoscere quei 1308 matrimoni che sono stati celebrati tra il 20 dicembre e il 6 gennaio 2014 (qui l'ordine). Facciamo un passo indietro. Se ricordate ancora, dopo che la Corte suprema aveva bloccato il prosieguo delle nozze, lo stato dello Utah aveva detto che a quelle coppie, che avevano celebrato le nozze in quell'intervallo di tempo, non sarebbero stati riconosciuti i benefici che già vantavano le coppie etero sposate (ad esempio non possono: fare la dichiarazione dei redditi insieme, prendere decisioni sulla salute del proprio coniuge, e così via). Da questo è nata una seconda azione legale, volta però a riconoscere a quelle circa 1308 coppie gli effetti giuridici dei propri matrimoni. In seguito il giudice Kimball si era espresso a favore delle coppie, dando però, qualche giorno di tempo allo stato dello Utah per appellarsi. Ora - e di nuovo - il 10° Circuito ha deciso in favore delle coppie, dando allo stato dello Utah appena 10 giorni di tempo per appellarsi e per ottenere una sospensione del dispositivo della sentenza.

mercoledì 9 luglio 2014

Italian mayor to ban gay kisses

Gianluca Buonanno
On July 9 Gianluca Buonanno (pictured with a bass) mayor of Borgosesia (Piedmont) and Italian MP for the Northern League, a racist-homophobic-secessionist party, announced that same-sex people who kiss will be fined 500. Buonanno is not new for his anti-gay and anti-Muslims slurs.







"Gay kisses in public? No thanks. Not only. From today in my Mayor and MEP offices there will be a photo of Putin" Buonanno says about of his new lover.

"I don't like that two people of the same-sex exchanges public displays of affection. It's a matter of respect. And I am convinced that is morally harmful for children". No comment please.

Buonanno and his new lover
Buonanno is Mayor, Italian MP for the Chamber of Deputies and recently member of the European Parliament. At the first seating of the European Parliament Buonanno arrived disguised in burqa.

Recently he has done everything possible to capture the attention of the media: he and a bass (above), he and bubbles; the European flag as a handkerchief.

LGBT associations has already condemned Buonanno initiative. The Democratic party mayor of a neighboring town said that he will made up a counter-initiative where everyone will have the opportunity to kiss his or her own lover.

If Buonanno will sign the act this will be maybe challenged in court. No chance of victory for Buonanno.

mercoledì 25 giugno 2014

Civil Union bill introduced

Monica Cirinnà
On June 24 Monica Cirinnà, Democratic MP, introduced the "Regulation of civil unions between same-sex couples and discipline of cohabitation" bill in the Italian Senate. The bill aims to recognize for the first time same-sex relationships as civil unions.











The bill which Cirinnà introduced on Tuesday is an unified version of many bills that were filed in the current legislature by MPs of different parties. 

Cirinnà hopes that the bill will "definitely approved before the end of the year", because she added that "we must fill a legal vacuum no more bearable ... the parliament must do in 6 months what it hasn't done in 8 years". About 8 years ago the center-left government tried to regulate the cohabitation of same and opposite-sex couples, but some Ministers and MPs that supported the Government threatened to leave the majority (the Catholic Church and even Pope Benedict XVI stepped in the debate and did all they could to block the bill).  

If the bill will be approved the Italian family law will change dramatically. This is a summary: Marriage will be available only for straight couples, Civil Union for gay and lesbian couple; than if you don't want to marry or to register your civil union you can still cohabit and receive some benefits or you could also stipulate a "cohabitation contract" with your partner.

Civil Union
In each comune (municipality, the plural forms is comuni) will be established the "National Register of Civil Unions" (Registro Nazionale delle Unione Civili) where gay and lesbian couples have the opportunity to formalize their union before the Registrar of the Civil Status (the state official). At least two witnesses must attend before the registration of the union in the National Register. When a couple writes down their names in the register the partners should decide the matrimonial regime. The registration of a civil union will grant to the two partners the same rights and duties of a married couple but not the right to adopt conjointly. However the partner will be able to adopt the child of the other partner.

Cohabitation 
Same and opposite-sex couples who don't want to register a civil union or to marry can cohabit and receive some benefits. Any contract that stipulates the cohabitation would be recorded before a notary. 

martedì 17 giugno 2014

Italian Rainbow Revolution

After the news released yesterday by L’Unità, according to one of the most read Italian newspaper, la Repubblica, Italy will gets its “Rainbow Revolution” when, in September, the Italian Parliament will start the debate over the recognition of same-sex unions.


Monica Cirnnà
On Tuesday 17, the Italian newspaper la Repubblica published that dealt with the issue of the recognition of same-sex unions. The journalist, Maria Novella de Luca, interviewed Monica Cirinnà the supervisor of two bills that will establish civil unions for gay and lesbians couples and cohabitation agreements for cohabitants couples either opposite or same-sex couples.

The Civil Union bill will grant to same-sex couples the same rights and duties afforded to married straight couples, indeed the Cohabitation agreement bill will grant to cohabitants couples some of the rights and the duties of marriage, because “who doesn’t got married, he or she doesn’t want to have all rights and duties”, Cirinnà says.

The paper version of the Tuesday article also reports two interviews, one to Giuseppina la Delfa, President of Rainbow Families, an association of gay parents and the other to the Catholic MP, Maurizio Sacconi who opposes Civil Unions for gays and lesbians, but backs the cohabitation agreement bill.

Giuseppina la Delfa, who writes for the Italian version of the Huffpost, strongly favors the two bills, but according to her the “real revolution” is the step-child adoption right that the Civil Union will grant to same-sex couples.

The two bills that will be introduced by Monica Cirinnà (Democratic Party) will start their debate in the Italian Senate Committee of Justice the next September.  

lunedì 16 giugno 2014

Italian Government to step in the Civil Union debate from September

Matteo Renzi - Italian Prime Minister
According to the Democratic Party newspaper, L'Unità, the Italian Government will introduce a bill that will grant to same-sex couples the same rights and duties afforded to married opposite-sex couples. 







The flamboyant Italian Prime Minister, Matteo Renzi (Democratic Party) promised for the second time the recognition of same-sex couples at celebration for the historic win at the European election (if you look at the picture you can recognize the result - 40.8%). According to L'Unità, the Italian Government - which is a great coalition government - will introduce a Civil Union bill for same-sex couples the next September.    

The same promise was made, if you remember, in December when Matteo Renzi was elected as the new secretary of the Italian Democratic Party. Now we will remember you what happened afterwards. First some Democratic MPs introduce the Civil Union and Cohabitation bill which would have grant to same-sex couples the same rights and duties afforded to married opposite-sex couples, then the Italian Senate assigned to the Justice Committee the bill and finally the same Committee tabled the debate over the recognition of same-sex couples and cohabitants. 

Monica Cirinnà
Later in May, after having carefully considered others bills relating to this issue, the supervisor, Monica Cirinnà ( Democratic Party), stated that she was ready to introduce a unified version of the bills which were took in consideration1

Due to the fact that the L'Unità didn't retrace this path as we did, it's easy to think that the Italian Government won't introduce a bill next September, but maybe, it will support the bill that Cirinnà has not showed yet. 

The bill that we will see in September won't be so different from the one which was introduced last December.

Last week the Italian Constitutional Court found unconstitutional a law that doesn't grant the same rights and duties of marriage to a married straight couple in which at least one of the spouses changes his or her legal gender and then see their marriage dissolved. The same court urged the Parliament to act immediately.

Italy is the last Europe founding state not to have recognized same-sex couples. Even Slovenia, Croatia, Hungary fare better than Italy on this issue. Malta, where divorce was not legal until 2011, legalized civil unions in April. 

In 1976 the Italian Constitutional Court gave the green light to the Parliament to legislate on the matter of cohabitation but we had waited a decade to see the start of the debate when, in 1986, a MP of the Italian Communist Party introduced a bill that regulated such a situation. Later other MPs followed suit but no bill was voted. In 2007 the Italian Government (center-left) tried to introduce a bill that would have regulated cohabitation but some Ministers and MPs that supported the Government threatened to leave the majority (the Catholic Church and even Pope Benedict XVI stepped in the debate and did all they could to block the bill). 

According to a survey released in late January, 78% of Italians backs the recognition of same-sex couples, 47% the right to marry and only 28% adoption for same-sex couples.   

---- Notes-----
1 According to the Italian laws, when a bill is introduced, the President of the Assembly (whether the Chamber of deputies or the Senate) assigns the bill to a Committee; then the Committee works on that bill - and on the others bills that maybe others Mps have introduced - and finally the Committee refers the final work to the floor. Finally the bill receive receives 3 votes - usually on the same day -  and then pass to the other assembly.

mercoledì 11 giugno 2014

Italian Constitutional Court upholds same-sex marriage ban in a transgender marriage case.

On June 11, the Italian Constitutional Court uphold a law that impose divorce to trans married person who change his or her legal gender. However the same court found unconstitutional the same law when does not recognize the partnership situation created due to the change in the legal gender. 



According to the decision, this new situation is no longer a marriage, but a situation which the Parliament should regulate as a registered partnership, the court writes.